Back to Blog


• 22 Jun, 2017

A data service, not a data portal

A data service is designed for all users, in all industries, and promises radically higher levels of reuse.

In the late 2000s, as more and more governments around the world began to adopt open data policies, we saw the rise of what has become known as the ‘open data portal.’ These portals came in many shapes and sizes, from the familiar tabular data catalogue to the many different kinds of ‘geoportal’ (read the ‘Spatial Reserves’ blog to get a sense of the breadth of the latter).

These portals were intended to improve on previous modes of data sharing, which included public servers and — most common of all — the classic ‘ask and maybe we’ll send it to you at some point on a hard-drive’ approach. These modes of sharing made it extremely difficult to find, appraise and access data; they also tended to require users to have technical expertise or individual relationships with agencies.

Ironically, all of this made the reuse of free public data an expensive undertaking. Reuse of public data distributed in this way was, to put it mildly, extremely limited.

Given this starting point, open data portals have been a great advance, and have helped a lot of people do a lot of great work.


The limits of data portals

Those that use data portals on a regular basis have always been aware of their limits. This is one of the reasons why we’ve seen such a proliferation of portal types, and why so many agencies around the world have decided — for better and worse — to build their own.

Every data portal, of course, has its own issues. To butcher Tolstoy, "effective data portals are all alike; every ineffective data portal is ineffective in its own way." Some portals lack proper API integrations; others lack a range of export formats; and others are just plain hard to use.

But there’s a growing consensus on what an effective data portal looks like. In March of this year, the peer network of urban Chief Data Officers across the United States, hosted by Harvard University, published ‘An open letter to the open data community.'

The letter is worth reading in its entirety (go on, I’ll wait). The general thrust of the letter is that the open data community — including users, publishers and technology providers — need “to set higher goals for open data to make it more accessible and usable. Our cities’ open data portals must continue to evolve to meet the public’s growing and changing needs.”

Growing and changing needs

The letter goes on to make eight specific recommendations, which generally fall into one of three categories:

  1. Better design and experience for end users.
  2. More features and functionality, including spatial support, layering, metadata management and revision history.
  3. Better experience for publishers, including automation of processes and pricing.

Without wishing to criticise, I actually think this list doesn’t set the bar high enough. Proper handling of metadata, good design, handling spatial and dealing with performance for large datasets — from my point of view, this all lies firmly in the category of ‘triage.’ The discipline of publishing data needs technology to catch up — it’s time for jet planes, not faster horses.

So, what have they missed? While we can always list more features, the gold standard for data publishing — the standard that we really ought to be aiming for as we talk about raising standards — is accessing all the data one needs (spatial and aspatial) in one place, with APIs and integrations into whatever software one is using.

This, coupled with the necessary improvements listed by the Chief Data Officers, effectively takes us into a different category of data distribution altogether. We could inelegantly talk about ‘the next generation of data portal,’ but that doesn’t do justice to the transformation this would represent—for the technology we use, and also for the outcomes we see in the world.

So, let me say it outright. The era of data portals — like the eras of public servers and ‘get in touch and maybe we’ll send you some data at some point’ — is finally coming to a close.

Active data and the data service

The limitations of first-generation data portals is fundamentally one of technology. They simply introduced too much friction into the user (and publisher) experience, dis-incentivising reuse — and dis-incentivising, in turn, greater investment in open data by agencies themselves.

As I’ve been arguing — here, and in my earlier blogs — the only way to truly realise the potential of open data is to remove the friction experienced by users and publishers, at every point in the data lifecycle.

When a ‘portal’ has achieved this transformation, it has ceased to be a portal at all — it’s evolved into a data service. A data service is fundamentally designed and engineered for all users, in all industries, and promises radically higher levels of reuse.

The data portal has been a great stopgap, helping agencies to ‘get their data out there,’ without necessarily achieving the potential articulated by open data advocates. But the era of the open data portal is at an end. And so, happily, is the era of dormant data, those hundreds of thousands of open datasets that are available somewhere on the internet, unloved and underused.

Anne HarperPosted by Anne Harper

Other News & Updates


• 16 Feb, 2022

New License and Site Category Management
We have fully rebuilt and are about to launch our license and site category management functions. This brings improved performance and usability to the platform, and helps you to curate and refine your data in more ways.Read More


• 23 Feb, 2022

Latest Desktop App release - v0.9.2
The latest version of our Desktop App has been released (v0.9.2) This represents extensive performance increases and other improvements to the App.Read More


• 23 Feb, 2022

Introducing Multi-factor authentication and Okta support for Koordinates ID
Built with OAuth 2.0, the dominant web authentication standard in 2022Read More


• 23 Feb, 2022

Koordinates QGIS Kart Plugin is now available
Allowing for direct Kart integration, get ready to unlock the full potential of QGISRead More


• 17 Nov, 2021

Koordinates now supports GDA2020
The latest Australian national datum for mappingRead More


• 29 Nov, 2021

Latest Desktop App release (v0.9)
Performance upgrades to enhance and improve speed and usabilityRead More


• 24 Nov, 2021

Spatial filtering for Kart and QGIS Kart Plugin
The latest Kart release completes a major new feature for spatial filtering repositories and adds an upcoming plugin for QGISRead More


• 30 Nov, 2021

New changes to our Data Management functionality
This feature lets a publisher/owner of data collect layers into a group, name it, and host it on their web portal.Read More


• 04 Mar, 2020

Sno, our new open source tool for distributed data versioning
Sno brings the distributed, version-controlled workflows of software development to geospatial and tabular data.Read More


• 19 Mar, 2020

Announcing Koordinates’ New Pro User Plan
We’re excited to announce our new entry-level Pro User plan for Koordinates Data Management.Read More


• 10 Dec, 2019

Announcing new-and-improved Data Management for Teams
We've upgraded our Data Management Team Plan — and reduced the price.Read More

Company Update

• 22 Nov, 2019

Why the world still struggles with open geospatial data publishing
Realising the potential of open geospatial data will require us to think of data publishing in a fundamentally different way.Read More


• 18 Sep, 2019

Why Koordinates supports many (many) different file formats
Koordinates supports a wide range of formats beyond GIS, including DWG, CSV, KML, and geospatial PDF.Read More


• 10 Sep, 2019

How Koordinates Solves the Problem of XML Metadata
Koordinates supports connected metadata sources, making it easier to publish and update XML metadata.Read More


• 20 Aug, 2019

How Koordinates Handles Data Uploads
Koordinates supports a classic 'drag-and-drop' workflow, with a few special features under the hood.Read More


• 15 Oct, 2017

Data is the key to unlocking the spatial revolution
Geospatial industry CMO Linda Stevens writes about the importance of unlocking Earth's data.Read More


• 23 May, 2017

From open data to active data
In 2017, it’s no longer good enough to just ‘get open data out there.’Read More


• 11 May, 2017

Solving the problem of dormant data
We now have the tools — policy, legal, cultural and technical — to solve the problem of data that is open but underused.Read More

Company Update

• 03 May, 2017

Talking Geospatial Data and Design
Next week our Head of Design, Dan Newman is talking at Techweek as part of the SIBA ‘Talk Geospatial’ breakfast series.Read More


• 23 Mar, 2017

Realising the vision of open data
The connected data lifecycle shows how agencies can raise the bar and publish their open data better.Read More

Company Update

• 15 Mar, 2017

Open data and the Stats NZ Datarama
We’re excited to be a partner for the Stats NZ Datarama next Friday, 24 March.Read More


• 10 Nov, 2016

The birds and the bees of software
A bit of magic happens when people from our various teams get together and cross-pollinate.Read More


• 06 Nov, 2016

The future of open data publishing
The internet is awash in authoritative government data, much of it freely available. But are we seeing a radical increase in reuse?Read More

Company Update

• 21 Oct, 2016

Design Research
The design team at Koordinates has been busy researching the workflows and requirements of our publishers and users.Read More

Company Update

• 17 Dec, 2015

Welcome Statistics NZ!
Statistics NZ recently launched the prototype of their data service on the Koordinates platform, with a view to making their statistical data more easily consumable for users.Read More

Company Update

• 17 Apr, 2013

Koordinates & the LDS win
The LINZ Data Service, built using Koordinates and supported by our engineers, won both the Spatial Enablement category and the JK Barrie Award for Overall Excellence at the Asia Pacific Spatial Excellence Awards.Read More

Company Update

• 23 Apr, 2013

Our CEO chats with Kim Hill
Koordinates CEO Ed Corkery was invited by the Royal Society of New Zealand and the National Library to talk about open data with Radio New Zealand’s Kim Hill.Read More

Company Update

• 05 Jul, 2013

Minister Williamson praises the LINZ Data Service
By making it quick and easy to find, check and view datasets, our portals have enabled public agencies to reuse public datasets that already exist, saving a heap of time and money.Read More

Company Update

• 13 Jul, 2013

New Zealand local government data
Local government datasets have huge social and economic significance, and are used by everyone from architects and data professionals to home-owners and ratepayers.Read More


• 13 Aug, 2013

Useful (and nice looking) open data
Students at Auckland University, spent their summer investigating how open data could help two groups, home buyers and professionals, make better decisions.Read More


• 13 Nov, 2013

LINZ Data Service and the Global Open Data Barometer
New Zealand has placed fourth on the Global Open Data Barometer.Read More


• 24 Jul, 2015

New Zealand National Broadband Map
The National Broadband Map allows you to enter your address and get an instant view of the different internet connection types available (or planned) in your area.Read More


• 29 Oct, 2015

Getting what you want - even when it's not in the box
With cloud technology changing the playing field of publishing and sharing data, more organisations are making the transition to new software.Read More

Company Update

• 28 Oct, 2015

The changing economics of data publishing and sharing
The business models and subsequent economics associated with making data available are also evolving.Read More


• 04 May, 2016

Mapping an ocean reserve at Cloud Break
Koordinates Customer Experience Manager Anne Harper helped map out the new Kurukuru Ocean Reserve in FijiRead More


• 25 Sep, 2023

Desktop App Public Beta
The Desktop App is now in public beta, meaning anyone can download and try it today!Read More


• 24 Sep, 2023

Try the 3D Map Viewer
Add another dimension to your data.Read More

Company Update

• 23 Sep, 2023

ISO27001 Certification
Ready to discover the secure, enterprise-grade geospatial data management capabilities of Koordinates?Read More


• 22 Sep, 2023

Web Plugin added to Giraffe
Our web plugin allows you to embed a Data Browser into any map-based web applicationRead More

• 20 Sep, 2023

Explore v10 UI
Take a in-depth tour of our new user interface, v10.Read More


• 26 Sep, 2023

Koordinates QGIS Plugin v2
The QGIS Koordinates Plugin v2 is now available to downloadRead More

Get started or get in touch

Our flexible product and pricing solutions suit a wide range of business and consumer needs. Sign up for free or talk to us about a tailored solution for your needs.